Court cases get twisted sometimes due to the nature of the case or the personas involved. Judge Judy has adorned our screens since 1996 with the highly acclaimed Judge Judy show, a series of small claims court sessions. Her shows are highly acclaimed due to her brassy and blunt nature, which adds a touch of chicness to the shows. Although the judge and the cast offer their audience a good laugh, the drama that engulfs the cast is worth a watch. Here are some of the most memorable Judge Judy cases we came across.
Top 10 Judge Judy Craziest Cases
1 – Motorcycle
If you are a fanatic of Judge Judy’s cases, you already know she despises interruptions and sideshows. Doing this may have you thrown out of the court or paying hefty fines. Judge Judy is honorable, but when she tells you to stop interrupting her judgment but you still interrupt, you might be fighting to have your case interrupted.
In the motorcycle case, among the most unbelievable Judge Judy cases, a motorcycle store owner went to court against a client who had rented one of his motors for three days. The client had issues and annulled the lease. The plaintiff wanted the client to pay for transaction costs, so he pushed the matter to the small claims court.
At first glance, the case looked normal, but the audience was shocked when the plaintiff kept a rude and entitled demeanor throughout the entire session. What surprised the court even more was that the court learned that the plaintiff was suing the client for charges incurred from the credit card company, which further complicated the case. In the end, the plaintiff did not receive any transaction costs.
2 – The Fake Case
If you have been a fan of courtroom drama, you must have experienced cases that seem oblivious. The fake case, aired in shocking Judge Judy episodes, is about Kate Levitt, who took her partner to court to seek a settlement for her cat’s demise.
In her file, she claimed that while she and her partner were engaged in a fight, he accidentally hit the TV, and it fell on their cat, leading to its death. However, this story was fabricated with no fight and no demised cat.
Levitt made up this story, hoping she would use the settlement to visit Los Angeles. Judge Judy saw through the façade because the case was inconsistent. Additionally, her partner’s story was off, and after hours of interrogation, Judge Judy annulled the case.
3 – The Horse Counterclaim
Judge Judy ensures that everyone involved in the case has enough time to plead their innocence or guilt. But this was not the case for the horse counterclaim case, one of Judge Judy craziest cases. Summer Ruegger, the defendant, wanted the plaintiff to pay the whole amount for a horse.
When Judge Judy dissected the case, she declared that the plaintiff should pay the defendant $1400 for the horse. Court documents stated that the plaintiff, Caroline, claimed to lease a horse to the defendant for $100 each month. In her statement, she said the defendant had not yet settled $1500.
Later, the plaintiff reversed her statement by saying she agreed to sell the horse for $1500 and that the defendant had to pay $100 monthly. Judge Judy dismissed the case after realizing that the defendant had cleared all her arrears and that Caroline just wanted to mint money from her.
4 – Missing The Dressing
If you are in the customer service field, you must be conversant with the pressure of the job description. Customer service workers handle all types of people, which was the highlight of this case, the missing dressing.
Dubbed one of the most bizarre Judge Judy cases, the missing dressing raised eyebrows, with many wondering why one would feel the need to bring such a minor issue to a small claims court. The plaintiff, a frequent restaurant eater, took a waitress to court because they forgot to serve him extra dressing as mentioned on the menu.
The plaintiff asked the hotel’s manager for a refund, but they declined. After a few days, the plaintiff visited the same restaurant and ordered a meal but refused to pay, claiming he opted to refund himself for the missing dressing. The plaintiff won $223 but was ordered to pay $12 for the meal.
5 – Push
If you spend your free time searching the internet for comical videos, you know how awkward it can get when you bump into glass doors. The Push, listed among the famous Judge Judy cases, is about a defendant with a running mouth during court proceedings.
Despite numerous attempts from Judge Judy asking him to keep calm and respect those in court, he continued with his outbursts. Finally, he stormed away from the court, and to his surprise, the door was made of glass, and he did not know how to get himself out.
6 – The Gasping Woman
Run-ins with the court can be a scary experience, especially for those who have disregarded the law. Devesha Thomas found herself on the wrong side of the law after the authorities learned that she had failed to renew her insurance.
She was facing either a fine or jail term, and when Judge Judy aired inconsistencies in her statement, she would gasp to feign ignorance. The gasps gave the attentive audience a hard time following up on the case since the gasps were exaggerated.
Devesha hoped her gasps would bear sympathy from the plaintiff and the judge. However, Judge Judy was unmoved by the gasps, especially after the defendant said he was unaware that the plaintiff had paid a $900 bill. The gasping woman case, dubbed one of the most memorable Judge Judy cases, ended in laughter because no one was moved by the gasps and poor acting skills.
7 – The Tupperware Assault
Most defendants exaggerate situations to get a better cut by the judge, and this case was no different, and neither was it a first for Judge Judy. The plaintiff took her neighbor to court, saying that she injured her with Tupperware.
Judge Judy was not buying the story, so she asked the plaintiff to explain the scenario and demonstrate how the fight transpired, including voice variations. The story raised eyebrows because the exaggeration was too much, even though the acting skills were on point.
Luckily, no one believed the plaintiff’s story, with most saying that it carried the day as one of Judge Judy’s craziest cases. In a twist of fate, Judge Judy asked the defendant to pay $192 in damaged Tupperware despite calling her an unstable individual because of circumstances.
8 – Losereds
A group of girls, headed by Alexandra Nelson, opted to take an assault case to the small claims court. However, their evidence and statement had discrepancies, and the story seemed fabricated.
After minutes of grilling, the audience and the judge concluded that Alexandra spearheaded the case to secure funding. Although the case itself was shocking, many were annoyed by Nelson’s aggressiveness towards the defendant, including using curse words.
Judge Judy seemed to have had enough of the insults and asked her why she was rude to the court. Alexandra explained that the defendant is a “losered”, massacring the English language instead of calling them a loser. Judge Judy awarded the plaintiff $4000 for reputational damage.
9 – You Are A Moron
This case is a must-watch if you are keen to see Judge Judy in full abrasiveness and no-nonsense mode. Highlighted by the masses as one of the most unbelievable Judge Judy cases, the plaintiff called the defendant a “moron” numerous times.
The case featured a couple who opted to divorce because the defendant had a major falling out with the husband. As Judge Judy is not new to parties throwing insults at each other during the court session, she went berserk when the defendant went after her child, calling her illegitimate.
The defendant was quick to defend her actions, stating that she believed parents should not keep secrets from their children. This statement charged the atmosphere, and everyone was shocked by the mother’s recklessness and disregard for the child’s emotions.
Although the child was born out of circumstances, Judge Judy ruled that children must not experience the wrath of adult arguments. The judge, angered by the defendant, called her a moron to her face thrice and stated that she is the reason she advocates for mental tests before people become parents.
10 – Venison Will Get You Nowhere
The “Venison Will Get You Nowhere Case,” one of the most famous Judge Judy cases, involves two sisters who take each other to court. The plaintiff claimed that the defendant took her car, as always, but things took a different turn because she ran over a deer.
The plaintiff appeared shaken, which came as a surprise to many. When Judge Judy inquired what happened to the deer, the defendant was unfazed and stated that she cooked it and shared it with her sister.
The courtroom went berserk, and the defendant did not understand why everyone, including her sister, acted shocked. However, in true Judge Judy fashion, she asked the defendant to pay the plaintiff $4000.
Conclusion
Judge Judy, a renowned New York judge from the small claims court, handles cases with vigor and austere. Although most people are synonymous with the shocking Judge Judy cases because they seem oblivious, they are legitimate and presented by real people.
